The Virtual Trophies, Blue Jays Edition

Ross Atkins and Mark Shapiro spoke to the media yesterday about the Blue Jays season and their outlook for the off-season. Both made veiled references to it being a disappointing season, but tried to frame it in a positive light by noting their 95 losses meant a #5 draft pick which could result in a major young talent if the scouts do their job right. Atkins admitted “candidly, at the start of 2019, I was not hoping to be picking fifth” – ie., have a team that approached respectability and finished higher in the standings – while Shapiro added he didn’t want to do that more than once. They admitted that the 21 starting pitchers used, with a collective ERA of well over 5 wasn’t good enough and that they needed to use any option available to improve there. All good signs if they do anything to follow through on the talk.

Anyhow, as is my custom at season’s end, I will give my picks for the “Blue Jays Awards”. And this year, alas, it was a bit difficult since… well, let’s call a spade a spade… there weren’t too many truly, obviously merit-worthy seasons. That said, my picks:

Player of the YearCavan Biggio yep, honestly that surprised me too. There were no totally obvious choices for this, and at first glance perhaps outfielder Randal Grichuk or MLB top prospect Vladimir Guerrero Jr. would have been the names to come to mind. Grichuk had career highs in a lot of categories including games, runs and homers and led the team in a number of significant categories including home runs (31), triples (5- more than the entire team managed last year) and RBI (80.) But his low batting average (.232), huge number of strikeouts balanced out with few walks and a low .280 on base, and so-so OF defense (even his biggest booster, Atkins, only called him “an average defender” yesterday) meant a low WAR of 0.3, lowest since his rookie year and the player himself calling it an “off year.”

Guerrero came up to more fanfare than any Jay in memory, and had the pressure of being the league’s top-rated prospect weighing on him. He smiled, he tried, he impressed at the Home run Derby and all-in-all was good. Excellent, for a 20 year old. But even his biggest fans have to grudgingly admit that his .272 avg., 15 homers, 26 doubles, and .772 OPS (not to mention a team high number of errors) were both A) decent for a rookie, but B) disappointing given the hype and what we’ve seen rookies like Juan Soto and Ronald Acuna do of late.

This leads us to Craig’s little boy. Cavan somehow, despite a great minor league record, wasn’t highly-rated by scouts but came up in early summer and played well, played smart. It wasn’t always obvious to me, as a fan over 1000 miles from Rogers Centre who more often looks at boxscores than the actual game in play, but Biggio may have been the most impressive player and posted the most impressive numbers of anyone on the team. Yes, the batting average was low (what do you bet his Dad reminded him of THAT!) at .234, but he has a Jose Bautista-like eye already and with 71 walks he posted a .364 on base and 16 HR, 48 RBI in 100 games. Baseball-reference somehow graded him a negative DWar (defense) though at second base, his usual spot, his fielding percentage of .989 bested the league average and he turned 44 double plays in 80ish games. His offense was solid though, meaning a 2.8 WAR. Add in a club high 14 stolen bases without being caught and little wee highlights like laying down a perfect bunt, the other way,when Tampa was playing the shift on him during the final week of the year, and running it into a bunt double and you have a lot of promise for 2020… and 2019’s Jay of the Year.

Pitcher of the Year Trent Thornton Remarkably, the team’s pitching statistically was closer to the league norm than their hitting. Nonetheless, even the architects couldn’t suggest that pitching was adequate this year. Making picking a best pitcher problematic. Some would argue for New York Met Marcus Stroman (deja vu– serious consideration was given last year to JA Happ, who like Stroman was traded to a Big Apple team at the trade deadline) . But while he was pretty reliable this season, he still posted a losing record and his attitude didn’t help out a lot . Reliever Ken Giles was great in his role as closer, but under-utilized and it’s hard to really justify giving a “Best pitcher” to a guy with 53 innings under the belt.

Which leads us to the bespectacled Thornton. At least he rose above expectations. A more or less throwaway from the Astros organization acquiired for infielder Aldemys Diaz, no one expected him to make the opening day roster let alone star on it. But he ended up being the only constant in the Jays starting rotation all year and got better as the year dragged on. A 6-9 record and 4.84 ERA aren’t real good, but might be best in show for the ’19 Jays. And he did lead in starts (29) and innings (154… . Roy Halladay is rolling in his grave). His strikeout to walk ratio was good, and he led the team in K’s too, with 149. Most impressively, he never gave in to tough opponents at the plate Kudos too for asking veteran Clay Bucholz to help him learn the curve ball and he actually was very good after doing so, having a 3.04 ERA from August 11 on. As a postscript,he went 2 for 3 at the plate too! One Jay who exceeded expectations.

Rookie of the Year – Cavan Biggio. Just stands to reason if he’s the Player of the Year and a rookie, he must be Rookie of the Year too. Kudos though to Guerrero, Bo Bichette, Thornton and even Danny Jansen for their years and making it the best single year rookie crop the team has ever posted.

Most Improved Player – Eric Sogard of Tampa. Yes, even though he was traded to the Rays late July, “The Nerd” stands out for his performance in the first 4 months of the season. After being a borderline backup infielder with few discernible major league talents, he came in and hit up a storm, motivated his teammates and quickly became one of the more popular members of the team for fans. In 73 games he was hitting .300 (the only regular to do so at that time), hit 10 homers – his past best was 3 in a year- and was slugging .457. His WAR in his Toronto time alone, 1.7 ,matched his one year career high. He ended up hitting .290 with 13 homers at season’s end and will have a chance to play post-season ball starting tonight with Tampa Bay.


  1. badfinger20

    I was really impressed with Bo Bichette what little I got to see him. I believe if he would have had more time he might would be the rookie of the year for the Jays.

    Cavan Biggio is a good pick…to offset his average the .364 OBP is very good. If the rookies don’t have a big sophomore slump next year they should be alright.

    Get some pitching and it should improve.

    • Dave

      Bichette was very good indeed, with his hitting streak to begin his career and being the only “almost regular” player to finish over .300 on the team, but I figured his 43 games played was just too few to really justify calling him the best of year. But it’s exciting to think how good the infield could be next year with him, Biggio and Guerrero.

      • badfinger20

        Oh I agree with the few games. I’m sure they will take their lumps in their second year when pitchers really start to adjust more and they will have to adjust back.
        I saw the Dodgers rookies go through it. Pederson, Bellinger, Seager…they still had good seasons but the 3rd season they picked it back up.
        The Jays have a very good nucleus to build on.

      • Dave

        They do and suddenly both Atkins and Shapiro are at least SAYING the right things, about taking the next step to become winners and spending if need be to boost the pitching. LA could be a little bit of a role model to some degree, like you suggest with a lot of young homegrown talent.

      • badfinger20

        They just have to stay on course and not change plans. They have a 6-7 year window before all of these players hit free agency…they need to add to them.

        Friedman took his Tampa Bay knowledge to LA…the trick is he can now keep people he couldn’t keep in Tampa. They have been under the Tax cap for two years now which pisses free agents off…but it’s working.

      • Dave

        yep, the system there seems to be working well. I hear rumors they might trade for Betts- what do you think of that possibility?

      • badfinger20

        I would love that trade. It would be for one year of course at the most but I would take it. He would not be cheap but since it’s only one year it probably wouldn’t take everyone to get it done.

      • Dave

        Boston will probably be anxious to shed his salary (especially if they can’t get rid of David Price- and I can’t imagine anyone would take him now at his “price”… many teams might trade for the pitcher if the Sox take probably half his remaining salary) so it might be easier to pull off than some would imagine.

      • badfinger20

        The Dodgers finally have Kemps and a bunch of others off of their payroll this off season. They are under the tax now barely and will be around 60 million under in a few months. They very well could get someone.

      • Dave

        I imagine they’ll do something but not go too crazy, of course, how they fare in Game 5 will make a difference I’m sure.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s